These cookies were pretty good. The oatmeal, dried cranberry and orange peel bits give a nice chewiness to it. It's got a nice crumb to it, perfect with my morning coffee. I was very excited about the metal tin! It has a little lamp inside and all the Christmas lights on the tin light up - so cool! The lamp light isn't that bright so it doesn't light all the way up, but I can easily switch up the light or put a candle inside. Love that i reuse this for years to come. A relative from London gifted this to us. I love what I've seen from M&S so far.